You are viewing gurugeorge

Guru George His Blogge - Post a comment
Mysticism, Magick, Philosophy, Politics and Economics
gurugeorge
Gyrus and contra Gyrus
Interesting reading some Gyrus on pro-noble-savage idea.  Granted people are safer in civilisation in terms of percentage chance of being killed if plonked into it, than they would be if plonked into an archaic culture, Gyrus questions whether the absolute loss of (say) 140 people now is better than the absolute loss of 1 person in archaic times.  It's a good point, but the counter is that Gyrus is forgetting that many more people are also enabled to live due to the same civilizing measures that are reducing the percentage chance of being killed. Plus, what we're interested in is not the sheer statistic or number (and minimizing and maximising that).  The statistics are a guide to making a choice; the point is to consider the situation of the average random person being plonked into X situation.  One only uses oneself as an example to get the point across of how it would be better or worse for anybody.

express yourself

No HTML allowed in subject

  
 
   
 

Notice! This user has turned on the option that logs your IP address when posting. 

(will be screened)

profile
P. George Stewart
Name: P. George Stewart
calendar
Back December 2013
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293031
Mission statement of this blog
To provide an open, ongoing, live record of an attempt at mystical attainment on the basis of an open-minded but fairly sceptical, scientific, rationalist and materialist outlook. Also to comment on other matters, especially politics, as the mood strikes me. And, er ... not to take myself too seriously.
links
tags